With warm watercolor artwork and a gentle storyline, this picture book sensitively looks at the issue of interfaith families. “Why can’t you be Jewish like me? Why can’t I be Christian like you?” To answer these questions posed by his granddaughter, a modern grandfather tells her the parallel story of Jethro, the famous non-Jewish grandfather of the Bible.
|Interest Level||Preschool - Grade 1|
|Reading Level||Grade 2|
|Publisher||Lerner Publishing Group|
|Imprint||Kar-Ben Publishing ®|
|Number of Pages||32|
|Dimensions||8 x 10|
|ATOS Reading Level||3.7|
|Accelerated Reader® Quiz||118736|
|Accelerated Reader® Points||0.5|
|Features||Awards and Reviewed|
- Sydney Taylor Book Award Notable
The Horn Book Guide
A gentile grandfather tells his Jewish granddaughter the story of Jethro (Moses’s Midianite father-in-law) and his Jewish grandson, Moses’s son Gershom. The parallels between modern-day family and the biblical one are effective, but the storytelling is confusing. An author’s note and the text itself promote the agenda of encouraging acceptance within interfaith families. Sand-color illustrations exude familial warmth.
In the past century, Jews, as well as other peoples, have increasingly been marrying out of the faith, merging cul-tures and religions into families. This book represents an attempt to deal with this issue as a young girl struggles to understand how she and her grandfather are related yet have different religions. The author compares this story to Jethro, Moses’s father-in-law, and Cershom, Moses’s older son. She discusses their relationship in the context of a grandfather explaining to his Jewish granddaughter that they can have a special relationship that is enhanced by their different religious backgrounds and beliefs. I found this book somewhat frustrating, as the author appears to gloss over the difficulties and confusion that happen when couples intermarry. She is also inaccurate, as the bibli-cal Jethro actually converted to Judaism. It was after Jethro converted that he came to visit Moses and suggested a system of delegation to judges to make Moses’s life as a leader more manageable. Because Jethro disapproved of the slavery in Egypt, he left there and settled in Midian. Amid great criticism, he offered hospitality to Moses and eventually became a Jew. If the author wants to help families deal with the challenges faced when intermarriage of religion occurs, she should avoid references to the Bible, which only accentuates the differences among faiths. In-stead, she could focus on ways we can work together, understand our various practices, and enjoy learning from one another. While our religious sources may be different, we all share common human characteristics and can enjoy hearing about and exploring one another’s religions and cultures.
School Library Journal
Author: Deborah Bodin Cohen
Deborah Bodin Cohen was ordained at Hebrew Union College - Jewish institute of Religion. She is the author of many children's books including the Engineer Ari series, The Seventh Day, Papa Jethro, and Nachshon Who Was Afraid to Swim. Her books have received numerous honors, including a National Jewish Book award, Sydney Taylor honor designations and the Sugarman prize. She lives in Rockville, MD, with her husband David and three children.